When a Pittsburgh couple bought a toy
box from Target for their daughter, they could not have known of the
tragedy that would result. Last summer, 2-year-old Camryn Surman
suffered a devastating anoxic brain injury after her air
supply was cut off; she is now in a persistent vegetative state.
A lawsuit filed by Camryn's parents
this week claims that the injury was a result of the toy box
purchased online from Target. The accident occurred when the lid of
the rectangular, wicker trunk fell and trapped her neck. Her parents'
attorney describes her condition as "as bad as it gets,"
requiring a feeding tube and constant care.
The lawsuit claims that the toy box was
unsafe, and that it should have included a lid support mechanism that
would have kept it from snapping shut; alternatively, it could have
included a warning of the potential risks. Target has removed the
trunk from their website, along with two similar trunks, but has not
yet issued a recall.
This tragedy is not the only one in
recent days to bring to light the serious issue of unsafe toys. Last
month, hundreds of thousands of wind chime toys were recalled
after reports surfaced that babies could pull them apart to reveal
sharp metal rods inside. After a 24-month-old baby punctured his
cheek with one of these rods, the company Tiny Love issued a
voluntary recall. These products were also sold at Target, as well as
other stores across the United States and Canada.
For concerned parents, the U.S.
Consumer Product Safety Commission maintains a list of toy hazard
recalls , and recalls.gov is also a valuable resource for
alerting American consumers about potentially unsafe or defective
products. Though government agencies work hard at regulating the huge
number of consumer products sold in the United States, it is also the
role of lawsuits like this one to encourage companies to test
thoroughly and to include all appropriate warnings – and perhaps
prevent tragedies like this in the future.